Guidelines for Papers (Academic Stream)
The guidelines below are for papers being submitted for peer review. Authors of papers that have been accepted should consult the camera-ready paper guidelines instead.
1. Carefully consider the paper review criteria
Peer reviewers will be asked to evaluate papers based on the following criteria and weightings:
a) Relevance: Appropriateness/fit for the conference theme and target audience (10%)
b) Aims and organisation: Clarity of aims/objectives, and organisation/sequencing of sections and content (10%)
c) Presentation: Adherence to IEEE conference and TALE style guidelines, and overall standard of presentation (10%)
d) Readability: How easy the paper is to read and understand in terms of language and writing style (10%)
e) References: Adequacy and suitability of literature references (10%)
f) Originality: The degree to which the paper makes a new and innovative contribution to research and/or practice (20%)
g) Scholarly Quality: Level of methodological and/or theoretical rigor and of reflective depth exhibited in the paper (30%)
2. Prepare the paper using the TALE 2018 Paper Template
Use of any other IEEE templates is not acceptable as there are subtle differences between those templates and the conference template that will affect the consistency in appearance of papers published in the proceedings.
Do not change the paper size (A4) or margins in the template.
The headers and footers must remain empty. (They should not contain page numbers or anything else!)
Formatting of the paper must be done using the pre-defined MS-Word styles in the template, rather than manually. The paper must use all the predefined font styles, sizes etc. as per the template.
Basic examples of citations and references are included in the template. For more comprehensive information on citations and references, see this guide. Note that where are conflicts between the template and the guide, the template prevails.
Page lengths must fall within the ranges listed below:
Full paper: 6 - 8 pages
Short paper: 4 - 6 pages
Work-in-Progress paper: 2 - 4 pages
Authors of Short papers may elect to present their work at the conference as either an oral presentation or as a poster.
Full papers may only be presented as at the conference as an oral presentation.
Work-in-Progress papers may only be presented as at the conference as a poster.
3. Prepare the paper for double-blind review
The TALE 2018 peer review process will be double blind. Peer reviewers will not be made aware of the identities of authors, and authors will not see the reviewers' identities. For this reason, author names and institutions must NOT be included in the version of the manuscript submitted for review. Only the final, camera-ready version should contain author and affiliation information.
Tips for ensuring double-blind review compliance:
Remove any identifying information, including author names, from file names and ensure document properties are also anonymised.
Ensure the paper itself does not contain any personally identifiable information (i.e., name, affiliation, email address, phone numbers, IEEE member number, etc.)
- Block out or obscure any affiliation-related identifiers that appear within figures in the paper.
Cite papers published by the Author in the text as follows: "[Anonymous, 2007]".
Use the third person to refer to work the Authors have previously undertaken. For example, replace any phrases like "as we have shown before" with "… has been shown before [Anonymous, 2007]".
Do not eliminate essential self-references or other references, but limit self-references only to papers that are relevant for those reviewing the paper being submitted.
Reference list entries needing to be anonymised should be presented as follows: "[Anonymous 2007] Details omitted for double-blind reviewing."
Remove any and all references to/mentions of funding sources.
Do not include acknowledgments.
4. Submit the paper
Once your paper is ready, save it in PDF format and submit it via the conference's online submission system, Conftool. Submissions cannot be accepted via email.